I'm new here at the boards, though I've been reading them for quite some time as many interesting discussions take place here. However, I was having lunch with some co-workers the other day, and the topic of the queen of fruits(what it is known as here in Bangkok), durian , came up. They explained to me that I should never eat durian and have alcoholic beverages at the same time, because it can result in death. They couldn't explain WHY one dies, only saying that durian 'heat' effect in combination with the alcohol will get too strong and overwhelm you. I've researched this a little but couldn't really find much of an explanation. Anyone else heard of this?
IP: Logged |
The durian is regarded as a 'hot' food as is alcohol. Apparently, consuming more than 1 'hot' food at a time is a guarantee of tummy upset. Instead, a 'cold' food, like mangosteen is suggested as an accompaniment. Man dies after over-indulging on fruit
AskYahoo! says: A page titled Durian Talk from the Bao Sheng Durian Farm in Malaysia also mentions the taboo against mixing alcohol and durians. Here's their explanation: "The flesh of the durian is rich in protein and when high protein mixes with alcohol it becomes yeast. You will feel uncomfortable and you may need to visit a doctor then."
Judging be what others have to say about the smell, I would think one would have to be inebriated to eat durian.
quote:Originally posted by Nolly: AskYahoo! says: A page titled Durian Talk from the Bao Sheng Durian Farm in Malaysia also mentions the taboo against mixing alcohol and durians. Here's their explanation: "The flesh of the durian is rich in protein and when high protein mixes with alcohol it becomes yeast. You will feel uncomfortable and you may need to visit a doctor then."
Becomes yeast? That's spontaneous generation!
And it doesn't make sense: yeast starts to die at around 12% alcohol. The hardiest yeasts can survive up to about 15%. (Which is why non-fortified wines only go up to 15% alcohol and anything over that is fortified with distillied spirits.)
-------------------- All posts foretold by Nostradamus.
Turing test failures: 6 Posts: 5481 | From: Decatur, GA | Registered: Nov 2002
| IP: Logged |
quote:Durians and alcohol : A common Malaysian belief is that it is harmful to drink alcohol after consuming durians. This belief dates back at least to the time of Rumphius (1741) who states that one should not drink alcohol after eating durians as it will essentially cause indigestion and bad breath. Gimlette (1929) in his ‘Malay Poisons and Charm Cures’ records: 'It is said that the durian fruit must not be eaten with brandy’. More recently, Croft (1981) states that '...a feeling of morbidity often follows the consumption of alcohol too soon after eating durian'. Some scientific studies have actually been conducted to investigate the validity of this belief. For the record, there is, in fact, a published medical instance of a middle aged Indian woman dying after eating a durian and consuming alcohol (Singh 1941). In this case, the woman was admitted to hospital complaining of intense epigastric pain, and persistent vomiting. Despite attempts to save her, she died several hours after admission. Autopsy revealed fat necrosis on the peritoneum, a reddish and swollen pancreas, a swollen main pancreatic duct, and 2 pints of blood stained fluid in the abdominal cavity. It was suggested by one physician that the death was due to acute haemorrhagic pancreatitis, the ingestion of durians that morning being merely coincidental; the patient had a history of epigastrium pain and discomfort for 7 months preceding her death. A second physician concurred and added that these conditions may have been caused by alcoholism. Oddly, the opinion of the author of the report was that the ingestion of durians and the death due to acute haemorrhagic pancreatitis was not coincidental, but perhaps causative. No explanation for this opinion was presented.
[edit--this was wa-a-a-y too long. I cut out detailed descriptions of several research studies]
In considering the available evidence, experiments with mice and rats, observations of humans (by Ogle and Teh), and the recorded medical case of Singh (1941), it is fair to say that consumption of durians with alcohol has not been shown to be harmful.
The article continues to mention a known health hazard of durians--falling fruits conking people on the head.
-------------------- The plural of "anecdote" is not "data." Posts: 4255 | From: Sacramento, CA | Registered: Feb 2000
| IP: Logged |